Most Popular High School Musicals - Top 10 School Musicals for Box Office Success

For many school theater programs, especially those with tight budgets, ticket sales are everything. Your box office income might be the single biggest financial support your program receives all year, and that means your show selection isn’t just an artistic decision... it’s a strategic one.

You need a musical that fills seats, excites your community, and (let’s be honest) can help fund next year’s production.

So how do you choose a musical that delivers both educational value and audience turnout?

Here are 10 musicals that tend to do exceptionally well at the box office, along with thoughts on what to consider for casting, budget, and production scope.

🎭 1. Beauty and the Beast (Disney)

There’s no denying it, Beauty and the Beast is one of the most beloved school musicals out there. With its enchanting music, memorable characters, and wide appeal across all age groups, it’s a certified ticket-seller. Families love bringing their kids to this one, and local audiences are usually thrilled to see it staged.

But be warned, it’s a beast in more ways than one. The technical demands are significant. From elaborate costume changes to magical effects (that transformation scene!), to a large, often intricate set, it can be one of your biggest undertakings.

• Strong draw for all ages
  

• Major costume/set/tech expectations
  

• Rights may be restricted depending on current tours—check early!

  NOTE: This title is currently restricted in North America as of this post: 8/4/25
  

☂️ 2. Mary Poppins (Disney)

Another Disney hit, Mary Poppins brings in a nostalgic crowd who remember the original film, while also captivating younger viewers with its magical story and visuals. It’s a feel-good, family-friendly production that nearly guarantees good ticket sales.

Many productions include flying effects for Mary (and sometimes Bert), which, while dazzling, can increase cost and complexity. Still, the music, characters, and charm of the show are more than enough to make it worth the investment.

• Highly recognizable and family-friendly
  

• Includes magic, potential flying effects, costume-heavy
  

• Ideal if you can cast strong singers/dancers and have tech support
  

📰 3. Newsies (Disney)

For something with a more contemporary edge, Newsies is a crowd-pleaser that feels fresh and energetic. Based on the real-life newsboy strike of 1899, it’s filled with powerful ensemble numbers and incredible dance opportunities. If you have a cast full of dancers—or students who want to dance—this show might be your winner.

The set can be simpler if you follow the scaffolding-and-platforms model from Broadway, and it doesn’t require as many costume changes as other Disney shows. However, you will need a cast that can handle the choreography and vocal work.

• Dance-heavy with exciting ensemble moments
  

• Flexible, creative set possibilities
  

• Skews male in casting—but can easily gender-flex some roles

👠 4. The Wizard of Oz

An absolute classic, The Wizard of Oz brings audiences out in droves. From the yellow brick road to the familiar songs to the Tin Man and the Cowardly Lion, it’s a beloved story that draws in families, senior citizens, and everyone in between.

It does require significant costuming and visual effects—especially if you want to go big with tornadoes, flying monkeys, or the Emerald City—but because it’s so widely performed, you may be able to borrow or rent costumes and sets from other local productions.

• High visibility and nostalgia factor
  

• Moderate-to-high tech and costume needs
  

• Strong roles for varied performance levels
  

🎼 5. The Sound of Music

A sweet, moving musical with strong name recognition, The Sound of Music is a smart choice if you have younger students or a multi-age ensemble. The von Trapp children roles are a great way to involve elementary or middle school students, while Maria, the Captain, and the nuns provide opportunities for more experienced performers.

The show’s beautiful music and heartfelt story mean a built-in audience, and its moderate staging and costuming make it more accessible than some other classics.

• Gentle pacing and familiar music
  

• Great for programs involving younger students
  

• Offers meaningful roles for female performers
  

🎺6. The Music Man

Filled with charm, humor, and catchy songs, The Music Man is a show that audiences love. Its Midwestern Americana vibe makes it perfect for community theater settings, and many older patrons will have fond memories of the film or stage version.

It’s ensemble-heavy and includes a barbershop quartet, which can be a fun challenge for strong male singers. If you can cast the quartet well and involve students or local performers across age ranges, this show can be a huge win.

• Crowd-pleaser with wide appeal
  

• Requires four strong harmony singers for the quartet
  

• Sets and costumes are flexible and scalable
  

🌈 7. Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

Joseph is a high-energy, fast-paced musical that’s fun for students and audiences alike. With its eclectic score (everything from calypso to rock-and-roll) and nonstop movement, it’s a blast to produce—and to watch.

The flexible ensemble and open casting possibilities make it great for schools with large groups, and it can be staged with minimal sets if needed.

• Upbeat, energetic, and accessible
  

• Cast can be all-gender flexible
  

• Great for choreography and group singing

👗 8. Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella

Cinderella is a fairytale with timeless appeal—especially to younger audiences. Little kids in princess dresses? Guaranteed ticket sales. It’s also a favorite with older audiences who remember the original Rogers & Hammerstein musical.

There are three versions: the classic, the "Enchated Edition" and the more modern Broadway update. The newer version includes on-stage costume transformations and expanded character roles—more magical, but more complex.

• Broad intergenerational appeal
  

• Excellent female lead and featured roles
  

• Transformation scenes require thoughtful tech planning
  

🎷 9. Hadestown Teen Edition

One of the newer shows on this list, Hadestown Teen Edition is perfect for schools looking for something modern, bold, and musically rich. Its jazz-club-meets-Greek-mythology vibe sets a unique tone and allows for artistic interpretation.

Not everyone in your audience may be familiar with it, but among teens and theater fans, it has a strong following. If your program is ready for something contemporary with depth, this could be a smart choice.

• Modern and relevant with poetic storytelling
  

• Visually flexible—can go minimalist or stylized
  

• May require extra prep if your audience isn’t familiar with the show

💋 10. Mean Girls: High School Version

Rounding out the list is the Mean Girls High School Edition, based on the iconic film. It’s a smart, sassy, and super fun musical with massive student appeal—and when students are excited, their friends and families show up to support.

It also opens up opportunities for school-wide conversations around bullying, social pressures, and kindness. That said, it’s dialogue-heavy and requires a strong ensemble of confident performers who can balance comedy and heart.

• Popular with teens = high audience turnout
  

• Promotes real-world conversation on school culture
  

• Adaptable sets and staging for a school-friendly version

Final Thoughts: Pick the Show That Works for You

Choosing the right musical is never just about what’s trendy or well-known. You need to weigh:

• Your cast’s strengths and size
  

• Your budget and available tech resources
  

• Your community’s tastes and expectations
  

• And, most importantly, your own excitement to direct it
  

Still, the musicals listed above have a solid track record of bringing people into the theater and helping school programs fund the future of their arts departments.

🎟 Want help planning your season? Make sure you’re signed up for my newsletter where I’ll be sharing a more show selction posts, castable show lists, and other tools to help you program confidently and creatively. If you sign up, I'll send you the FREE Drama Classroom Toolkit as a gift. It also inclues a link to a free Show Production Checklist.

Happy teaching, and break a leg at the box office!